✦Theology Snapshots
← Back to the journal

Christian living · Music & technology

A Friend Sent Me a Quote About AI Music

Buddy King · October 22, 2026

A message I received

Recently, a friend sent me something he'd seen on social media.

AI and music do not belong in the same universe. AI "music" isn't music. It's soulless math and algorithms you can hear but shouldn't. Only humans and angels can make music.

I've always been open that my songs are AI-generated, so I didn't take this as a gotcha. I took it as a fair observation from a brother. I decided to take time and think it through with Scripture.

My AI Music Journey

About a year ago, a brother at church and I challenged each other to memorize Ephesians 2:1-10. I was hesitant, because I have never been good at memorizing large portions of Scripture.

It occurred to me that I can remember song lyrics from 25 years ago or more, with no effort. What if I could put Scripture to music?

I searched Google, and the first result was Suno. I started experimenting, and before I knew it, I had memorized Ephesians 2:1-10 through AI song.

Soon after, our church started a weekly Men’s Bible Study. Part of our time together is memorizing Scripture, and I've used AI-generated songs to memorize every passage we've taken on. The latest was the first chapter of James. I memorized the entire chapter, and I would never have managed that without the songs.

You can listen to these Scripture songs on my YouTube channel, Word & Cadence — Scripture Set to Music.

I recognize that the ends don't justify the means, and I'm still wrestling with this. Here are some of my thoughts.

Where I agree

The vocals in my songs are synthetic. There is no person behind that voice who lived the words and is offering them to God. I won't pretend otherwise.

This is where my real struggle is. It isn't the music or the arrangement. It's the voice. Music has always carried something personal from the singer to the listener, and I can't deny that part is missing.

What I actually do

My lyrics are always biblical text, with no added interpretation. Some songs follow the verses in order. Others vary the translation, or mix translations within a single verse. It is always Scripture.

I have also tried writing songs of my own with original lyrics. None of them felt right, and I scrapped every one.

The music I create takes hard work and many hours. I often go through a hundred or more rounds of listening and refining. Sometimes the tool gives me something I like quickly, but I still fine-tune most of the time. I discard many voices that don't sound right. I'm not pressing a button and posting the result.

What Scripture says, as far as I can tell

I went looking online and found biblical arguments from people on both sides (using AI to search the internet 😊). One argument is that John 4:24 says worship must be in spirit and truth, and a song has no spirit. But I don't see the song as the one worshiping. I am. The generated song is a tool, the same way an instrument is a tool.

Of the arguments I came across, if one from Scripture resonates with me at all, it is this one: the idea of a "new song" that comes from lived experience, as in Psalm 40:3. It speaks to the synthetic voice.

My answer is that the soul isn't completely absent. A person is directing the work, choosing what stays and throwing out what doesn't. Scripture honors skill and craft, as in Exodus 31, and this takes real craft. When the result resonates with me and leads me into worship, I don't think it is soulless, even where the voice is concerned.

A matter of conscience

These songs have helped me. I have memorized and meditated on more Scripture than in my entire walk, and it comes back to me during prayer. That's real fruit.

But again, the ends don't justify the means, and I'm not using the benefit as my argument. If I came to see that it was wrong, I would stop, whatever it had given me.

I don't find a clear biblical case against using AI as a tool for this. I also don't find one that settles it. For me, that leaves it in the category Paul describes in Romans 14, a matter of conscience, where each person has to answer before God. Today my conscience is clear, and I'll keep testing it.

Thank you

Thank you to my friend for sending this and helping me work through it. I'm more convinced now about using AI as a tool, including the voice, than I was before.

Join the conversation

Please keep comments gracious, on topic, and respectful. Comments and reader replies are reviewed before appearing. Your email stays private and is not displayed or used to subscribe you to a mailing list.

Loading comments…